Hybrid efficiency put to the test

Despite common perception, the advantage of hybrids over frugal diesels is often illusory, if judged solely on fuel economy. Having tested over 30 hybrids in the UK and US, Emissions Analytics is able to analyse the data to understand how they really perform.

To illustrate the point we have taken a sample of 10 vehicles tested since 2013 – two standard hybrids versus 8 diesels – from the real-world fuel economy testing we conduct with What Car? in the UK. Each has an engines in the 1.5 to 2.2 litre range, power up to 150bhp, two-wheel drive and with hatchback, saloon or estate body style. The table shows the sample, ranked by fuel economy with the best MPG at the top:

Make Model Engine Size Derivative Fuel Transmission True MPG
Honda Civic 1.6 i-DTEC ES Diesel Manual 67.2
Skoda Octavia 1.6 Greenline III TDi CR Diesel Manual 61.9
Peugeot 308 1.6 Allure BlueHDi Diesel Manual 60.8
Mazda 3 2.2 SE-L Nav Skyactiv-D Diesel Manual 59.4
Toyota Auris 1.8 Touring Sports Icon VVT-I Petrol hybrid Automatic 58.7
Citroen C4 Cactus 1.6 Flair e-HDI Diesel Automatic 57.8
Toyota Yaris 1.5 Excel VVT-I Petrol hybrid Automatic 57.8
Peugeot 2008 1.5 Feline e-HDi Diesel Manual 57.7
Volkswagen Golf 1.6 Bluemotion TDi Diesel Manual 56.8
Honda CR-V 1.6 i-DTEC SR Diesel Manual 56.5

While hybrids deliver good fuel economy in real driving, they can be eclipsed by up to 10mpg by some non-hybrid diesels. And that is after having taken into account any net changes in battery charge levels, to ensure that the hybrids are not penalised over our cycle. For certain driving patterns however, hybrids may still be the better option. Over our complete dataset of more than 500 vehicles in the UK, we can quantify how average MPG changes under congestion and aggressive and fast driving.

Urban congestion penalty Urban aggression penalty Extra urban benefit
Diesel -6.0% -8.4% 18.4%
Diesel hybrid -2.5% -12.9% 1.1%
Petrol -8.3% -6.5% 27.4%
Petrol hybrid -3.3% -7.5% 8.5%

What this data shows is that hybrids suffer much less than their ICE equivalents under congested urban driving: on average a 3% penalty compared to 7%. In contrast, by doubling the average rate of acceleration the MPG falls by more for hybrids, especially diesel hybrids.

Comparing motorway driving to town driving, all types of vehicle show better MPG on the former, but the difference between hybrids and ICE vehicles is dramatic – typically because the downsized engines found in the hybrids are less suited for high speed motorway cruising.

Even more than their tolerance of congestion, the value of hybrids may be in their pollutant emissions, as even the cleanest diesels typically exceed the regulated values of NOx. In a recent report by the International Council on Clean Transportation, which analysed data from Emissions Analytics, the average exceedance was seven times for the latest Euro 6 diesel cars.

This compares to petrols, which generally meet the regulated NOx standards, even in real-world driving. Carbon monoxide is higher for the petrols, but again within the regulated values. Therefore, petrol hybrids have the benefit over ICE diesels in their effect on air quality, made even better as a proportion of urban driving will be on battery, with zero emissions. Although not included here, plug-in hybrids can show this pattern even more strongly.

In summary, hybrids deliver good but not best-in-class fuel economy, but they are typically the cleanest, and if you are a light-footed, congested town driver, they are ideal.

Menu